The surge worked

News and commentary originating in and affecting the USA

The surge worked

Postby Bill Whatcott » Thu Jan 17, 2008 8:57 pm

The Wall Street Journal
The surge worked

Jan. 10, 2008
By John McCain and Joe Lieberman

It was exactly one year ago tonight, in a televised address to the nation, that President George W. Bush announced his fateful decision to change course in Iraq, and to send five additional U.S. combat brigades there as part of a new counterinsurgency strategy and under the command of a new general, David Petraeus.

At the time of its announcement, the so-called surge was met with deep skepticism by many Americans -- and understandably so.

After years of mismanagement of the war, many people had grave doubts about whether success in Iraq was possible. In Congress, opposition to the surge from antiwar members was swift and severe. They insisted that Iraq was already "lost," and that there was nothing left to do but accept our defeat and retreat.

In fact, they could not have been more wrong. And had we heeded their calls for retreat, Iraq today would be a country in chaos: a failed state in the heart of the Middle East, overrun by al Qaeda and Iran.

Instead, conditions in that country have been utterly transformed from those of a year ago, as a consequence of the surge. Whereas, a year ago, al Qaeda in Iraq was entrenched in Anbar province and Baghdad, now the forces of Islamist extremism are facing their single greatest and most humiliating defeat since the loss of Afghanistan in 2001. Thanks to the surge, the Sunni Arabs who once constituted the insurgency's core of support in Iraq have been empowered to rise up against the suicide bombers and fanatics in their midst -- prompting Osama bin Laden to call them "traitors."

As al Qaeda has been beaten back, violence across the country has dropped dramatically. The number of car bombings, sectarian murders and suicide attacks has been slashed. American casualties have also fallen sharply, decreasing in each of the past four months.

These gains are thrilling but not yet permanent. Political progress has been slow. And although al Qaeda and the other extremists in Iraq have been dealt a critical blow, they will strike back at the Iraqi people and us if we give them the chance, as our generals on the ground continue to warn us.

The question we face, on the first anniversary of the surge, is no longer whether the president's decision a year ago was the right one, or if the counterinsurgency strategy developed by Gen. Petraeus is working. It is.

The question now is where we go from here to sustain the progress we have achieved -- and in particular, how soon can more of our troops come home, based on the success of the surge.

Gen. Petraeus has already announced that five "surge" brigades will be withdrawn by mid-July. The process is now underway. The Pentagon has also announced that it is conducting a series of internal reviews to examine whether and when additional troops can be withdrawn -- with Gen. Petraeus, the Joint Chiefs of Staff and U.S. Central Command each asked to offer their own analysis. As the president awaits these recommendations, it is important for the rest of us to keep some realities in mind.

First, it is unknown whether the security gains we have achieved with the surge can be sustained -- and deepened -- after we have drawn down to 15 brigades. Until we know with certainty that we can keep al Qaeda on the run with 15 brigades, it would be a mistake to commit ourselves preemptively to a drawdown below that number.

As the surge should have taught us by now, troop numbers matter in Iraq. We should adjust those numbers based on conditions on the ground and the recommendations of our commanders in Iraq -- first and foremost, Gen. Petraeus, who above all others has proven that he knows how to steer this war to a successful outcome.

Every American should feel a debt of gratitude to Gen. Petraeus and the great American troops fighting under him for us. This gratitude is due not simply for the extraordinary progress they have accomplished in Iraq, but for what they have taught us about ourselves.

If the mismanagement of the Iraq war from 2003 to 2006 exposed our government's capacity for incompetence, Gen. Petraeus' leadership this past year, and the conduct of the troops under his command, have reminded us of our capacity for the wisdom, the courage and the leadership that has always rallied our nation to greatness.

As Americans, we have repeatedly done what others said was impossible. Gen. Petraeus and his troops are doing that again in Iraq today.

The war for Iraq is not over. The gains we have made can be lost. But thanks to the courage of our troops, the skill and intellect of their battlefield commander, and the steadfastness of our commander in chief, we have at last begun to see the contours of what must remain our objective in this long, hard and absolutely necessary war -- victory.


Mr. McCain is a Republican senator from Arizona. Mr. Lieberman is an Independent Democratic senator from Connecticut.
:cross:Christ is the answer!
User avatar
Bill Whatcott
Administrator
Administrator
 
Posts: 6769
Joined: Sun Sep 23, 2007 11:33 am
Location: Edmonton, AB

The surge worked

Postby Banned_from_FD » Sat Jan 19, 2008 12:16 am

ummm,

i hate to break old news to you

but Al Sadr declared a cease fire several months ago, that is why there is less violence right now

Al Sadr is waiting out the "surge" which is scheduled to end in a very short time due to the fact the Yanks have plain run out of fresh troops

so i will bump this post next fall when cease fire ends and the civil war heats up again
User avatar
Banned_from_FD
FNA Teacher
FNA Teacher
 
Posts: 1412
Joined: Mon Sep 03, 2007 2:13 pm

The surge worked

Postby zip.com » Sat Jan 19, 2008 3:13 am

\"Banned_from_FD\" wrote:ummm,

i hate to break old news to you

but Al Sadr declared a cease fire several months ago, that is why there is less violence right now

Al Sadr is waiting out the "surge" which is scheduled to end in a very short time due to the fact the Yanks have plain run out of fresh troops

so i will bump this post next fall when cease fire ends and the civil war heats up again


I think I'll go with what General Petraeus has reported, rather than Wikipedia. Thanks anyway! :roll:
Abortion: The Human Sacrifice to the god of Convenience.
User avatar
zip.com
FNA Employee
FNA Employee
 
Posts: 937
Joined: Fri Aug 17, 2007 7:09 am
Location: Ontario, Canada

The surge worked

Postby Banned_from_FD » Sat Jan 19, 2008 8:58 am

when did i mention wiki?

all news outlets reported the cease fire

give me a few minutes and i will find a Patreas quote describing the affect of the cease fire by Al Sadr
User avatar
Banned_from_FD
FNA Teacher
FNA Teacher
 
Posts: 1412
Joined: Mon Sep 03, 2007 2:13 pm

The surge worked

Postby Banned_from_FD » Sat Jan 19, 2008 9:02 am

Well that did not take long, just type "Patreas" and "cease fire" into google news and you can find the General talking about it all the time.

------------------------------------------------------------

Major improvement in Iraq security: Petraeus
Posted Sun Dec 30, 2007 9:15am AEDT

Top US commander in Iraq General David Petraeus says there has been a remarkable improvement in the country's security over the past year.

General Petraeus says violence in the country has dropped by 60 per cent since June and civilian deaths are down by 75 per cent on last year's figures.

The steady reduction in violence has been most noticeably felt in Baghdad.

There are a number of factors behind the drop, including an increased US military presence, more and better-trained Iraqi troops and a cease-fire by the most aggressive Shiite militia.

[size=18px]The US military says Moqtada al-Sadr's decision to call a six-month cease-fire in August has helped to improve the security situation. [/size]

But perhaps the most important aspect is the emergence of Sunni militias, who once fought the Americans and the Iraqi Government but are now fighting Al Qaeda.

-BBC



any comment Zip, now that I have proven my point?
User avatar
Banned_from_FD
FNA Teacher
FNA Teacher
 
Posts: 1412
Joined: Mon Sep 03, 2007 2:13 pm


Return to American News

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest

cron